{
 "variant": "H",
 "status": "accepted-without-external-text-review",
 "at": "2026-09-24T06:35:19.799514+00:00",
 "reviewer": "Text panel v02 after the owner’s direction «TEXT SHOULD BE MORE SONG LESS NARRATIVE»: two lyricist angles per variant (chorus song; rhymed story-song), a music-director judge per variant, a breath pass (T) and a rhyme pass (H), native and meaning/claims refuters with adversarial verifiers on the final texts; complete-source listening from the Gemini 3.8 Flash composition review composition-v01 (source heard in four parts). Two external re-reviews of the v02 texts (composition-v02, composition-v03) returned provider code 500 and were not repeated further.",
 "method": "Every phrase, beat-map grid, cell and causal link of the v02 text checked against the 39-thought meaning map, product truth, owner-fixed forms and the addendum craft rules (chorus, rhyme, images, no fragments), with tools/beat_map.py scans and the build_v4 prediction; serious findings kept only when an adversarial verifier confirmed them; the complete source was heard in composition-v01. Accepts preparation only.",
 "limitations": [
  "No external listening review of the v02 TEXTS: composition-v02 and -v03 failed at the provider (code 500); the external composition review of the source-heard kind exists only for the narrative v01 drafts.",
  "Text and source audit cannot establish any sung stress, groove or musical quality; the first audition remains unaccepted.",
  "Source evidence supplied as four transport pieces, not continuous human listening."
 ],
 "ownerDirection": {
  "version": "v02",
  "at": "2026-09-24T04:34:26Z",
  "authority": "Owner, this session (chat), 2026-09-24",
  "ownerWords": [
   "bro stop song style if shit all shit",
   "AND YOU CAN FUCKIMH CHANGE TEXTS BUT DONT MESS WITH TARG STYLE IN SUCH A HARD WAY",
   "ITS ONLY ABOUT SOUNDING CRIPS AND SHARP AND AS PRODUCED BY BEST MUSICAL PRODUCERS; TEXT SHOULD BE MORE SONG LESS NARRATIVE"
  ],
  "choices": [
   "«New style from Targ» (one style from the original’s own sound for both variants, shown before any purchase)",
   "«Even lighter touch» (almost nothing about the arrangement; the Targ seed carries the style; only the crisp mix and the vocal are named)"
  ],
  "replaces": {
   "T": "Ukrainian folk-pop with a prescribed drum pattern, strummed guitar eighths and delivery instructions",
   "H": "Ukrainian pop ballad on a half-time groove, D major, piano and bass"
  },
  "style": "Same style as the original: acoustic folk-pop, about 103 BPM, F major. Ukrainian female lead with the original's warm timbre, sung from the first word. Crisp, sharp, top-producer radio mix: tight drums, clean bass, bright upfront vocal, every word clear and on the beat.",
  "neg": "spoken word, rap, narration, instrumental intro, fade-in, muddy mix, lo-fi, reverb wash, slurred words, rushed lyrics"
 },
 "textChanges": "v02 = chorus-song base (judge): mirror chorus ×3 («Дивлюся у дзеркало — бачу чужу, / Питаю: «Хто ж ти така?»» + згасло → знову → «Це ж я — і те світло в очах моїх!»); rhyme pass (V1–V3, V6, bridge opening); refute fixes: «до́нечка грала у залі», «з жалем гляділа», «я бачу Ларису», «без лущення»; builder rule: a chorus line with the same syllable count returns to the first return’s rhythm («Це ж я́» on the beat).",
 "rejected": [
  {
   "finding": "p13, p14, p26, p30 (serious on one lens)",
   "reason": "verifiers: not errors (poetic dative ellipsis; first-person narration; a list inside one sentence is allowed; figurative «блідіші» = fainter)"
  }
 ],
 "prediction": {
  "syllables": 561,
  "phrases": 54,
  "plannedRests": 30,
  "thoughtBoundaries": 37,
  "sungRate": 2.44,
  "maxSectionRate": 2.67,
  "maxSection": "v3",
  "hookReturns": 3,
  "codaFactsRested": 6,
  "duration": 258.6,
  "durationBasis": "sung seconds from the map + 0.8 s per planned rest + one bar per fill and before the brand; the bar-framed map length (intendedSeconds) is an upper bound — iteration 3 sang shorter than its frames",
  "restBoundaryShareRange": [
   0.33,
   0.45
  ],
  "restBasis": "iteration 3: planned rests are not predicted by the text; [Pause] tag lines gave 0.31–0.44 of boundaries, no layout reached 0.80",
  "content8Within40": 0.494,
  "content8Within40Range": [
   0.454,
   0.534
  ],
  "content8MAD": 46.4,
  "crispnessBasis": "weak-groove model (A/B phrases): lower seed weight, half-time style; ternary regularity has weaker evidence than binary (mixed per track)",
  "mapContentStressesOnBeats": 1.0,
  "mapStressOnBeats1and3": 1.0,
  "meanBinaryFit": 0.213,
  "meanTernaryFit": 0.707,
  "sylPerContentStress": 2.81,
  "sixteenths": 0,
  "models": {
   "fitKey": "anyreg",
   "strong": [
    {
     "lo": 0,
     "hi": 0.34,
     "n": 15,
     "within": 0.42,
     "mad": 50.4
    },
    {
     "lo": 0.34,
     "hi": 0.67,
     "n": 25,
     "within": 0.529,
     "mad": 42.1
    },
    {
     "lo": 0.67,
     "hi": 1.01,
     "n": 17,
     "within": 0.549,
     "mad": 38.5
    }
   ],
   "weak": [
    {
     "lo": 0,
     "hi": 0.34,
     "n": 36,
     "within": 0.438,
     "mad": 50.7
    },
    {
     "lo": 0.34,
     "hi": 0.67,
     "n": 44,
     "within": 0.47,
     "mad": 46.4
    },
    {
     "lo": 0.67,
     "hi": 1.01,
     "n": 21,
     "within": 0.553,
     "mad": 45.7
    }
   ]
  }
 },
 "trend": {
  "baselines": {
   "A": {
    "content8Within40": 0.458,
    "content8MAD": 48.3,
    "sungRate": 2.7,
    "maxSectionRate": 3.26,
    "hookReturns": 3,
    "codaFactsRested": 6,
    "restBoundaryShare": 0.396
   },
   "B": {
    "content8Within40": 0.486,
    "content8MAD": 43.1,
    "sungRate": 2.68,
    "maxSectionRate": 3.01,
    "hookReturns": 3,
    "codaFactsRested": 6,
    "restBoundaryShare": 0.333
   },
   "targ": {
    "content8Within40": 0.613,
    "content8MAD": 29.8
   }
  },
  "floors": {
   "sungRate": 2.9,
   "maxSectionRate": 3.3,
   "hookReturns": 3,
   "codaFactsRested": 6
  },
  "predicted": {
   "content8Within40": 0.494,
   "content8MAD": 46.4,
   "sungRate": 2.44,
   "maxSectionRate": 2.67,
   "hookReturns": 3,
   "codaFactsRested": 6,
   "syllables": 561,
   "duration": 258.6
  },
  "moves": {
   "content8Within40": true,
   "content8MAD": false,
   "sungRate": true,
   "maxSectionRate": true,
   "hookReturns": true,
   "codaFactsRested": true
  },
  "allMove": false
 },
 "declaredTest": "Owner H2 asks to test at least one variant that writes its own meter with a higher styleWeight. The evidence model (iteration-3/v2 phrases) predicts H at 0.51 on the grid with a 46 ms median deviation — not better than B on the deviation row — so H does not pass the H9 trend rule and is bought ONCE as the declared own-meter test, not as the expected winner; ternary regularity has weak evidence in our data, and the test tells whether a half-time ternary setting sits tighter than the model can predict.",
 "evidence": [
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/preparation/panel/brief-v4-song.md",
   "sha256": "d6f0281f742f5cadf1856f2ea2025856117094d9b4d3335bf3862b668c75c224"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/preparation/panel/song-v02/refute-T-v02.json",
   "sha256": "bd996cbd70feaecf2dd132fefdc2c7889fb41aaed5512ff8223506028243f935"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/preparation/panel/song-v02/refute-H-v02.json",
   "sha256": "a1959f1bd580375b898a1c957965ac4cb01203fce1d8bf0ebc1343439b479ef1"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v02/receipt.json",
   "sha256": "aec90ffea27485694febe48b252344031a04924c9af7abba4d24ed63aec8f85d"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v02/response.json",
   "sha256": "a2af1439b6ac4862f731ff7b0ff3e5c78594d586f49bdda1e5d0eb16714cad96"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v03/receipt.json",
   "sha256": "fe20ba6dcce7f230dcd7aa884917843a66a88874ad2cdae4518da9256f50491f"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v03/response.json",
   "sha256": "a2af1439b6ac4862f731ff7b0ff3e5c78594d586f49bdda1e5d0eb16714cad96"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/preparation/director-decision-composition-v03.json",
   "sha256": "db969d0422aef44953530983362702cd8984aae6222a264547ccf76bf9a0abb2"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/plan/variants-v01.json",
   "sha256": "7b3876267ed5f118fbbea13e3fb0f6e1fe818e40c3a01be89eb0ab026600ff1a"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/preparation/panel/song-v02/design-H-song-v02.json",
   "sha256": "d000b0a28744c78d7d8a25364bcb0ea636c50971a8166f821244dc3ccf0a7f82"
  }
 ]
}