{
 "variant": "H",
 "status": "accepted-with-revisions",
 "at": "2026-09-24T04:19:50.206750+00:00",
 "reviewer": "Gemini 3.8 Flash composition review (complete source in four audio parts, both texts with beat-map grids, iteration-3 texts A and B), 1.51 credits by receipt",
 "reviewOutcome": {
  "readyForFirstAudition": true,
  "scores": "singability on grid 5, stress 4, idiom 5, rhyme/meter 4, hook 5, breath 5, budget 4, advertorial 4, development 5"
 },
 "directorDecision": "H is bought once as the declared own-meter test after two fixes (a disputed stress removed; the week-six line keeps both named defects resolved with a perceptual framing). Its predicted crispness (0.493, 46.4 ms) is not better than B on the deviation row, so it is not the expected winner.",
 "findings": [
  {
   "finding": "p06 stress зиму́ → зи́му",
   "decision": "accepted as an ambiguity",
   "action": "зиму́ (pinned dictionary, uk.wiktionary) against зи́му / за́ зиму (reviewer); «за зиму» removed: «А я за пів року постаріла років на п’ять.» also restores the source span «in six months» (t08)"
  },
  {
   "finding": "p14 «бліду світлину» abstraction",
   "decision": "rejected",
   "reason": "t15 «the before version of the woman her husband loved first» is a photo metaphor; the reviewer calls the line musically smooth; «при́вид тіє́ї, що ві́н коха́в» loses «before version»."
  },
  {
   "finding": "stress flag ки́слоти → кисло́ти (p24)",
   "decision": "rejected",
   "reason": "Owner-fixed inherited form (NEXT_SESSION_PROMPT_SONG_V4.md lines 50 and 83: plural «ки́слоти»); СУМ-11 «кислота́, -и́, мн. ки́слоти, -ло́т»; the version-2 кисло́ти was the mis-stress caught by the native refuter on 2026-09-17 (runs/targ-song-v3-08f0d414c5-v01/preparation/panel/refute2-B-native.json)."
  },
  {
   "finding": "p33 borderline absolute claim «ні смуг, ні заломів»",
   "decision": "accepted in part",
   "action": "«Шість тижнів — не вірю: ні смуг, ні заломів не видно.» — both defects named resolved (week three sang «заломів поменшало»; owner rule 21), said as what she sees"
  },
  {
   "finding": "information budget: 50 ml omitted",
   "decision": "rejected",
   "reason": "Bottle size is neither a source thought nor one of the six ordering facts."
  }
 ],
 "applied": [
  {
   "phraseId": "p06",
   "from": "А я за зиму постаріла на п’ять літ.",
   "to": "А я за пів року постаріла років на п’ять.",
   "why": "composition stress flag p06 accepted as a real ambiguity: зиму́ (pinned dictionary, uk.wiktionary) against зи́му (reviewer, stem-stress pattern of за́ зиму); the word is removed and the source span «in six months» restored (scan clean, cost 1.45, three bars)"
  },
  {
   "phraseId": "p33",
   "from": "Шість тижнів — не вірю: ні смуг, ні заломів.",
   "to": "Шість тижнів — не вірю: ні смужки не видно.",
   "why": "composition forbidden-claim p33 accepted in part: the complete endpoint stays (owner rule 21, product truth refreshNote), said as what she sees; «ні смужки» echoes Larysa’s p21 «а на шиї ні смужки» (scan clean, cost 1.45)"
  },
  {
   "phraseId": "p33",
   "from": "Шість тижнів — не вірю: ні смужки не видно.",
   "to": "Шість тижнів — не вірю: ні смуг, ні заломів не видно.",
   "why": "meaning and native lenses (serious; verifiers split 1 real / 1 not real): week three sang «заломів поменшало», so a week-six line naming only «смужки» leaves the creases at a reduced remnant — owner rule 21 makes that a failure; director keeps both named defects AND the perceptual «не видно» that answered the composition claim flag (scan clean, cost 1.6, three bars)"
  }
 ],
 "evidence": [
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v01/evaluation.json",
   "sha256": "422d2e7766bcf0d32e692248f1da25256b652cec0aa96c17cf44026751d976c6"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v01/response.json",
   "sha256": "f528d7b8ef680735acf4c0b394a18e4eb8ef8122c61667e6b405de39fd38ae4f"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v01/receipt.json",
   "sha256": "60ce19e23101b63a9cce8f1318a9032c2015d70b7b4849f1c06b1bc76e14ea87"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v01/review.md",
   "sha256": "32df946ea2b3bd79bfea647770178d79e81ee01964f6e3cfe00270435bf16eef"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/reviews/composition-v01/request.json",
   "sha256": "dd3598cebe6dc4928e8558c4e861e2908b020581839a8f5f68300386d2714160"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/preparation/panel/refute-v012-changes.json",
   "sha256": "12e33e347b9c74d746ed6ef9bdd8561e611ee7e56d8ee85281e4d0064898de40"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/references/gopure-product-20260914.json",
   "sha256": "953c232211d0366e5f22f67bc2f2df728b630d95e662e04103442a4e3580fbc4"
  },
  {
   "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/f5c3870848/runs/targ-song-v4-f5c3870848-v01/song/source-thoughts-v01.json",
   "sha256": "e17fa9355887b5ba213457e7c7f4e1c67a4fbef0075b41956da1ea36d9b6f52e"
  }
 ],
 "prediction": "H after revisions: 0.493 (0.453–0.533), 46.4 ms, 2.47 syl/s, densest 2.61, ~265 s; trend allMove false (deviation row) → declared own-meter test, one request."
}